Home
Articles
Landscaping and Maintenance
Fresh Wood Chips As Mulch?
Since the major ice storms in Virginia counties caused severe damage
to trees, many counties are giving away all the mulch that one can haul.
Concerns have arisen as to the effect, if any, that this fresh mulch will
have on plants if put down now.
Per Dr. Donald Rakow, Director of Cornell Plantations, there
are three primary concerns. First, is that any diseases on the wood can
be transferred to ornamentals. According to George Hudler (also at Cornell
-- Department of Plant Pathology), it is very unlikely that the right combination
of factors (pathogen, susceptible host, environmental conditions) will
come together to spread diseases in this way.
The second concern is that naturally occurring allelopathic chemicals
will be transferred directly to susceptible plants. In research that Dr.
MacDaniels conducted in the 1950s, he found that he could not induce wilting
in susceptible solanaceous plants when planting them directly into fresh
black walnut wood chips. Many do not consider this a problem, but there
has been no follow up on this research. Bark and fruit contain the concentration
of juglone, but very little is in the wood itself; this may account for
Dr. MacDaniels' findings.
Lastly, there is the concern about the fresh wood chips tying up nitrogen
during their decomposition. An article by Frank Gouin (University of Maryland)
states that wood chips (as opposed to pine bark) have a very wide C:N ratio,
and that they do cause significant nutrient deficiencies, particularly
for herbaceous plants.
Mark White (Professor, Wood Science and Forest Products, Virginia Tech)
has done research on the pH of wood leachates and reports that they are
quite acidic and could significantly change soil pH depending on the volume
used. Since they can be in the pH 4 range, the acidity could both damage
the plant and plant roots immediately and reduce could reduce soil pH with
repeated applications. Large trees and plants that require an acid soil
can survive this situation better than tree seedlings and most herbaceous
plants.
According to Jim May (Research Associate, CSES, Virginia Tech), if
fresh wood chips are applied in too thick of a layer, the heat generated
as they begin to compost can injure herbaceous plants.
More research is being conducted by a PhD student at Cornell, so additional
information should become available in a few years.
|